In Andrew Jackson, Trump finds a flawed role model

Unlike most presidents, Trump doesn’t consider himself a student of history. He’s not much of a reader, and the speech he delivered at the Hermitage Wednesday may be the closest thing to a presidential biography he’s read.

By Rick Holmes  / Opinions/Mass. Political Editor / March 24, 2017

 

NASHVILLE – The Hermitage, the plantation home of President Andrew Jackson, was closed to the public Wednesday for a special visit from President Donald J. Trump. So I went out on Tuesday, looking for links between presidents number 7 and 45. They aren’t hard to find.

Unlike most presidents, Trump doesn’t consider himself a student of history. He’s not much of a reader, and the speech he delivered at the Hermitage Wednesday may be the closest thing to a presidential biography he’s read.

But Trump seems to have found his presidential role model. After the election, people started comparing Trump’s victory to Jackson’s populist uprising in 1828, and the president-elect warmed to the narrative. He ordered a portrait of Jackson hung prominently in the Oval Office.

At the Hermitage, Trump underlined the association, calling himself “a big fan” of Old Hickory.

Jackson “defied an arrogant elite,” Trump said. “Sound familiar?”

As the audience laughed, Trump mugged: “Oh Andrew, I feel your pain.”

The similarities between the two presidents go deeper than just populist rhetoric. Jackson and Trump both ran for office as outsiders challenging the Washington establishment, both consider themselves champions of the working man.

Both were celebrity candidates. Jackson was the hero of the Battle of New Orleans. Trump built his brand through real estate deals and reality TV. Jackson invented the modern political party by building an organization around himself. Trump staged what amounted to a hostile takeover of the GOP.

170315_POL_Jackson-Trump.jpg.CROP.promo-xlarge2

JAMELLE BOUIE: Trump sees himself in Andrew Jackson and deserves the Jackson legacy, but not for the reasons he’d like to think.  READ MORE


Both believe in the strong executive. Jackson greatly expanded the powers of the presidency. He paid little heed to the preferences of the Congress, the rulings of the Supreme Court or the obligations of treaties with the Indians, including the ones he negotiated and signed. Trump is already clashing with the courts over his own sweeping executive orders.



Jackson was quick to perceive insult and retaliate with violence. He participated in dozens of duels, often to defend his wife’s honor against scurrilous charges. One duel left a lead slug lodged in his chest, inches from his heart, that plagued him for the rest of his life. Trump fires off tweets, not bullets, but he shares with Jackson a quickness to take offense and a tendency to hold a grudge.

“Everything about politics was, to him, personal,” according to Jackson biographer Jon Meacham. Jackson had “the biggest ego you ever saw in your life,” says historian Daniel Feller. Sound familiar?